Do I Have to Believe in This for it to Work?
Kelly McHugh | JUN 8
The honest answer, for the skeptics and the curious.
This is one of the questions I get most often, usually asked a little tentatively, as though the person is bracing for me to say yes - that belief is the whole mechanism, that without it there's nothing to receive. I want to set that worry down right at the start: no. You don't have to believe in energy healing for it to do something.
That said, there's a more interesting version of this question underneath the obvious one, and I'd rather get to that.
When people ask if they have to believe, they usually mean a few different things at once. Do I have to believe that energy is real? Do I have to be spiritually open? Will my skepticism somehow block the work? Am I disrespecting you by not being sure this is real?
These are all different questions, and they deserve different answers.
On whether energy is real: I can't prove the biofield to you in a lab, at least not yet. The research on Healing Touch and related modalities is promising and growing, but the mechanism isn't fully understood. What I can tell you is that the effects - relaxation, better sleep, reduced pain, emotional clarity, a settled nervous system - are documented and real. Whether those effects happen because of something subtle in the energy field, or because the parasympathetic nervous system responds to stillness and skilled, attentive touch, or because of the placebo response (which is real and powerful and not nothing) - I don't know for certain, and I'd rather say so than oversell it.
On being spiritually open: You don't need to be. Healing Touch is not a religious practice. It has no doctrine. It's compatible with any spiritual orientation you hold, and equally compatible with none. I work with people across a wide range of beliefs, including people who don't have much use for the word "energy" at all and come anyway because something about lying still and being tended to makes them feel better.
On skepticism as a blocker: This is the most interesting part. In my experience, skepticism doesn't block the work. A skeptical nervous system still responds to stillness. A skeptical body still shifts into parasympathetic when given the conditions. I've had people come in with significant doubt and leave saying something happened, even if they couldn't name what. I've had people leave still skeptical and also report they slept better than they had in months. Both are fine outcomes.
If belief isn't required, what actually helps? A few things:
Willingness. Not belief - just the willingness to lie down for an hour and be present with whatever happens. That's it. That's the only entry requirement.
A reasonable openness to not knowing. If you come in committed to proving it doesn't work, you might be managing that agenda the whole hour instead of resting. There's a difference between healthy skepticism (I'll see what happens) and defended certainty (nothing will happen). One is easy to work with. The other can make the hour less restful.
Hydration and a meal. Genuinely. The practical preparation matters more than the mental preparation.
The placebo response is real. I don't say that to undermine the work - I say it because dismissing it would be inaccurate. When a person believes they're receiving care, their body responds. That response is physiological. It involves the nervous system, the immune system, measurable brain activity. Calling it "just placebo" misunderstands both the word and the biology. If you receive a session, feel deeply rested, and attribute it to the power of lying quietly for an hour - I'm not going to argue with you. The rest is real either way.
You don't have to believe in energy healing for it to work. You have to be willing to show up and see. That's the whole bar. Bring your doubt if you have it - it's welcome on the table.
Kelly McHugh | JUN 8
Share this blog post